By Trevor Thorn · Published
Choosing the right building contractor is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when planning a home extension or renovation. It’s tempting to compare quotes and go with the lowest price, but there’s much more to consider if you want your project to run smoothly and finish as expected.
At Thorn Homes, we’ve been building for over 20 years, and we know that every homeowner and every project is different. Here’s our advice on what to look for when choosing your contractor.
1. Decide What Level of Service You Need
Not every building contractor operates in the same way. Some are small teams or independent builders who specialise in particular parts of a project, while others offer a complete, end-to-end service.
At Thorn Homes, we manage projects from the initial building work through to the finishing touches, including flooring, carpets and landscaping. With an established team, trusted subcontractors and dedicated office support, we aim to take the pressure off homeowners by managing the entire process.
This level of service comes at a cost, as running an established business involves more overheads. A smaller contractor may be able to offer a lower price, particularly if you only need the structural work completed.
Neither approach is automatically right or wrong. The key is to understand what you’re paying for and choose a contractor whose service matches your expectations.
2. Don't Choose on Price Alone
It’s natural to focus on the bottom line when comparing building quotes, but the cheapest quote isn't necessarily the best value.
An unusually low price may reflect a genuine saving, but it could also mean that certain items have been underestimated or excluded altogether. If these costs emerge later, your budget could quickly increase.
We've seen projects in Gloucestershire where homeowners have chosen a contractor based primarily on price, only to find the work left unfinished. While this doesn't mean a lower-priced builder is necessarily a risk, it highlights why it's important to look beyond the initial figure.
At Thorn Homes, we believe in charging fairly for the service, experience and resources we provide. Our aim is to deliver a well-managed project, with clear communication and attention to detail from start to finish.
3. Compare Quotes Like for Like
Before making a decision, take the time to go through each quote carefully. Don't assume that two contractors have included the same work simply because their proposals appear similar.
Pay particular attention to:
- What's included: Check that materials, labour, finishes and other essential work have been accounted for.
- Provisional sums: These are allowances for work or items where the exact cost hasn't yet been established. Make sure the allowances are realistic and comparable across all quotes.
- Structural steel: Check that the allowances for steelwork are consistent. A lower allowance can make one quote look considerably cheaper than another.
- Finishing work: Confirm whether items such as flooring, decorating, carpets and landscaping are included or will cost extra.
- Potential additional costs: Ask how unexpected issues and changes will be dealt with during the build.
For example, if one contractor has allowed £6,000 for structural steel and another has allowed £4,000, the second quote may initially look more attractive. However, if the realistic cost is closer to £6,000, you need to account for that difference before comparing the overall figures.
The more detail you check at the quotation stage, the better informed your decision will be.
4. Look at Communication and Project Management
Building work can be disruptive, particularly when you're extending or renovating the home you live in. Having a contractor who communicates clearly and deals with questions promptly can make a significant difference to your experience.
Ask how you'll be kept informed, who your main point of contact will be and how decisions or unexpected issues will be handled.
At Thorn Homes, we aim to deal with costs and issues as they arise rather than leaving everything until the end of the project. Our customers can contact the office for support, and our director, Trevor Thorn, makes his personal mobile number available on project paperwork and contracts.
We believe that being approachable, answering questions and addressing concerns promptly are essential parts of delivering a good service.
5. Check Their Experience and Track Record
Before appointing a contractor, do your homework. Look at previous projects, ask for references and find out how long the business has been operating.
It's also worth understanding the resources behind the company. Does it have an established team? Does it work with reliable subcontractors? Can it manage your project within the timescale proposed?
At Thorn Homes, we've been operating as a limited company for 18 years, with more than 20 years of building experience. We have an established team and a network of trusted subcontractors, allowing us to manage a wide range of extension and building projects.
A contractor's history and reputation can provide useful reassurance, although no single factor guarantees that a project will run perfectly. Take the time to check that their experience and approach are right for your particular job.
6. Choose Someone You Can Work With
You'll likely be dealing with your contractor for several months, so it's important to feel comfortable with the people managing your project.
Do they listen to what you want to achieve? Do they explain things clearly? Are they willing to answer questions and discuss concerns? Do you feel confident that they'll take your priorities seriously?
Trust and communication matter just as much as the figures on the page. A competitive quote is of little comfort if you struggle to get answers or feel uncertain about what's happening on site.
Take your time, meet the people involved and choose a contractor whose approach gives you confidence.
7. Understand Availability and Timescales
A contractor who can start immediately isn't necessarily a better choice than one with a waiting list. Equally, a busy contractor needs to be realistic about when they can begin and how they will resource your project.
Established businesses have teams, subcontractors and existing commitments to manage. Smaller contractors may have more flexibility, depending on their workload.
Ask for a realistic start date, an indication of the project duration and confirmation of how the work will be organised. Make sure these expectations are clearly discussed before you commit.
Do Your Homework Before You Build
Choosing your building contractor is about much more than finding the lowest quote. It's about understanding what's included, checking the details, assessing the experience behind the business and deciding what level of service you need.
The more research you do before work begins, the better placed you'll be to make an informed decision and avoid misunderstandings further down the line.
At Thorn Homes, we're proud of the service we provide to homeowners across Gloucestershire, from initial building work through to the finishing touches. If you're planning an extension or renovation and want a contractor to manage the process from start to finish, we'd be happy to discuss your project.
Planning a home extension?
Get in touch with Thorn Homes to talk through your ideas and find out how we can help.
Get in touch

